The Rain in Spain Falls Mainly on the Plain

DSC01152_2 (2)_2Marie Saward met 66-year-old British real estate tycoon, Paul Saward, on the romantic island of Majorca. After marrying in 2009, they resided in the Mediterranean port city of Alicante, Spain. But two years after their dream marriage, the romance was over with Mr. Saward vowing that his wife wouldn’t get a penny from him.

Mrs. Saward returned to England where she applied for a divorce arguing that her estranged husband’s legal residence was in the United Kingdom and thus she was entitled to have her case heard in England.

Apparently the first judge who heard her case agreed and granted her the divorce she sought, but it was a fleeting victory. Mr. Saward applied to set aside the divorce decree on the basis that the British court had no jurisdiction over him because his permanent residence was in Spain.

Mrs. Saward valiantly argued that her husband maintained personal ties and had significant real estate holdings in his home city of Southampton England. She also claimed that her ex-husband often made disparaging comments about Spain.

But to Mr. Saward’s delight, the second judge overturned the divorce decree finding that his “permanent and fixed centre of interests” were in Spain. She said:

“Although the husband may well have expressed a dislike of Spain in forceful terms on many occasions, and whilst he may have contemplated a return to the UK, he had made no concrete plans to do so.”

Judge Lesley Newton referred to a letter written by Mr. Saward in 2011 that read:

“I have no plans of ever moving back here, I could not put up with the weather … only two days left and I will be home.”

Mrs. Saward appealed the new order but was unsuccessful. Why was she so determined to have the English court preside over her divorce? Firstly, because British courts are well-known for making generous financial awards to women and secondly, the law in Spain only provides for a division of property between legal or common law spouses if the property is held jointly by the couple. Property in one party’s name is not sharable.

All the assets owned by Mr. Saward were in his name alone, leaving his wife with nothing, just as he threatened when the marriage broke down.

What about the law in Canada? Under the Divorce Act if one spouse ordinarily resides in Canada, the courts will take jurisdiction to grant a divorce and deal with property and support claims as well.

Mrs. Saward is left with nothing, but frankly, how much could she really expect after such a brief marriage. Not much.

Lawdiva aka Georgialee Lang

About these ads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s